Keith Insurance

About Us

Keith Insurance represents over 20 different insurance companies, enabling us to shop your insurance to find you the best coverage for the most affordable price. Our automobile insurance companies include Nationwide, Progressive, Travelers, The Hartford, Safeco, MetLife, Bristol West, GMAC, and Agency Insurance Company. We also write homeowner's insurance for over 10 major companies, striving to make sure Lee County's residents can find coverage at an affordable price. The agency takes pride in helping Lee County's small business owners save money, while providing them with excellent customer service and satisfaction. Keith Insurance also offers Life insurance and financial planning services, giving their clients and families a sense of security.


Troops Insurance

Terry Keith

tkeithHi, I’m Terry Keith, President of Keith Insurance. In 1982, I started my business with a 50 cent Bic pen, a sports coat, and a dream of helping Lee County’s residents. I received my Bachelor’s degree from Miami Of Ohio, majoring in business management. A few years after I graduated college I moved down to Fort Myers and opened a Nationwide Insurance Agency. After 25 years of being an exclusive Nationwide Agency in Lee County I formed Keith Insurance, which has given us the ability to write from over 20 different insurance companies, including Nationwide. Although my son, Ian Keith, has joined the family business, I am still extremely active in the day to day operations of the company.

Ian Keith

ikeithIan graduated from Florida State University in 2009 with his degree in Insurance and Risk Management, which currently ranks 3rd in the nation among public and private universities. Ian holds licenses in property & casualty insurance, as well as life, health, and variable annuities. In addition, Ian holds his commercial lines coverage specialist designation.

Community Involvement: Born and raised in Fort Myers, Ian’s dedication to the Southwest Florida community is evident through the many organizations he serves. His passion for giving back spans from helping people on a personal level to raising funds, spreading awareness, and bringing attention to local charities and not-for-profit organizations. Ian is a proud and active Rotarian and is a past president of The Rotary Club of Fort Myers (2019-2020), making him the youngest president of the oldest Rotary club in Southwest Florida. In addition, Ian serves on the board for LARC which is an organization that promotes and provides opportunities for people with developmental disabilities to live, work and participate in their communities.

Honors and/or awards: Ian has received numerous awards locally and in the insurance industry, some of which include Safeco Insurance’s Make More happen Award (2015 & 2019), Hartford Volunteerism Award Recipient at the AARP Aces Community Service Awards (2018), and Southwest Florida’s 40 under 40 award (2019). Ian’s involvement in The Rotary Club of Fort Myers has garnered him several awards including Service Above Self Award (2011-2012), Young Knights to The Rescue Award (2016-2017), Pinnacle of Service Award (2017) and Rotarian of the Year (2018).